Long Island Top Homemade Pies
🥧 Grab a slice...
Facts about Pies:
- There is a Pie Town and it is located in New Mexico
- National Pi Day is 3.14 (and of course celebrated with some pie!)
- Pie's were not always considered dessert. In the 19th Century, pies were a common breakfast food- we can get on board with that!
- There is an American Pie Council (yep!) and they celebrate Pie Day on January 23rd
- Thanksgiving was declared a National Holiday by Abraham Lincoln just a few months after the Battle of Gettysburg and pumpkin pie can be credited by Sarah Josepha Hale in celebration.
North Shore- Nassau
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178510/Screen Shot 2020-09-21 at 4.40.53 PM.png?w=610)
Glen Head- Youngs Farm
Baked from scratch in their kitchens, this great farm is a must-stop for delicious pies- make sure to try the dark cherry pie.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178478/jericho 2.jpg?w=610)
Jericho- Jericho Cider Mill
Must stop spot for all things apple- cider, cider donuts, and apple pie. Try their other delicious options too!
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178474/Dianes Bakery.jpg?w=610)
Roslyn- Diane's Bakery Café
Tucked underneath the bridge in Roslyn is this quaint spot with plenty of pies to satisfy.
North Shore- Suffolk
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177157/Blondies.jpeg?w=610)
Centerport- Blondies Bakeshop
Place your orders for holiday pies and keep an eye out for their mobile bakeshop- the Little Blonde Truck.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177151/Hometown.png?w=610)
Centerport- Hometown Bakeshop
extensive assortment of savory and sweet pies which are perfect for just about any gathering
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177154/Sweetie Pies.png?w=610)
Cold Spring Harbor- Sweetie Pie's & Gourmet Whaler
brings in freshly made Young Farm pies- the Dark Cherry Pie as seen on Verizon's Restaurant Hunter is amazing! Place your holidays orders early. They also serve miniature pies from Fiorello Dolce.
Gourmet Whaler just a few doors down is headed by Denise Chin who, along with her team, produces delicious baked goods including your holiday pies and quiches.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177162/Fiorello Dolce.png?w=610)
Huntington- Fiorello Dolce
assortment of delicious freshly made pies in assorted types and sizes. The miniature pies are a treat!
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177166/Buttercooky.png?w=610)
Huntington- Buttercooky
Try one of their daily selections or order one from their extensive list.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1177173/Kerbers Farm.png?w=610)
Huntington- Kerber's Farm
when you stop at Kerber's you feel as if you've been taken a trip out-east. Their pies are fresh and delicious. The Smores Pie is a stunner and our own Joyce loves their seasonal key lime pie.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1179200/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 2.59.02 PM.png?w=610)
Melville- White Post Farms
National Pie Competition winners for their Pecan ad Apple Crumb. You are sure to find a slice of heaven here.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1179197/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 2.57.32 PM.png?w=610)
Northport- Copenhagen Bakery
pies are one of the numerous bakery items which this harbor-side bakery produces each day. Go for a sweet pie or try their savory chicken pot pie.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1179167/Hummel Humme.png?w=610)
Northport- Hummel Hummel Bakery
choose from a variety of seasonal pies and don't forget to check out their famous pizza crumb.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1991369/Screen Shot 2022-10-31 at 1.59.05 PM.png?w=610)
Port Jefferson- Torte Jeff Pie
Offering classics and fresh takes on sweet and savory pies including vegan options
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/2463251/Screenshot 2023-11-06 at 12.54.17 PM.png?w=610)
Rexer Family Farm
Offering 4 options for fillings
South Shore
Babylon- Torta Fina
Head to Babylon to this quaint shop with a delicious assortment of pies- oh! that caramel apple pie!
Eastport- Olish Farms
What a selection of pies! Choose from all your favorites including sugar free options.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1991364/Screen Shot 2022-10-31 at 1.51.00 PM.png?w=610)
Islip- Manhattan Sweets | Boutique Bakery
People on TripAdvisor love this boutique bakery
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1991447/Screen Shot 2022-10-31 at 3.00.17 PM.png?w=610)
Patchogue- Mademoiselle Patisserie
Delightful pastries year-round with quiches but be sure to check back at the holidays for pies.
North Fork
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178526/Screen Shot 2020-09-21 at 5.04.52 PM.png?w=610)
Cutchogue- Wickham's Fruit Farm
Daily made from their own grown fruit trees on their own bicentennial farm
Jamesport- Hallock's Cider Mill
Fresh homemade pies found here along with various other goodies.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178809/Jundas.png?w=610)
Jamesport- Junda's Pastry Crust & Crumbs
Perched in a classic white house this bakery features delicious cookies and shortbread crust.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178861/Briermere Pies.png?w=610)
Riverhead- Briermere Pies
This is the spot for pies! Renown for their pies, be sure to order head around the holidays
South Fork
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178673/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 9.37.07 AM.png?w=610)
Bridgehampton, Fairview Farm at Mecox
Pick up Meredith's Famous Pies here- they are happy to supply them fresh or frozen.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178672/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 9.35.13 AM.png?w=610)
East Hampton, Carissa's The Bakery
has beautiful unique pies to impress the foodies on your guest list. (And yes- that's a pie in that picture not just art!)
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178668/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 9.32.39 AM.png?w=610)
East Hampton, Round Swamp Farm
In addition to classic fruit crumb pies (Raspberry Peach, Tri-berry, Apple, and more), they bake a large variety of their family recipes.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1178677/Screen Shot 2020-09-22 at 9.42.24 AM.png?w=610)
Southampton, Blue Duck Bakery Cafe
Blue Duck Bakery has multiple locations and delivers their baked goods to various locations on LI.
![](https://api.curaytor.io/sites/213/media/1991429/Screen Shot 2022-10-31 at 2.24.35 PM.png?w=610)
Hampton Bays, Krieg's Bakery
Mince pies are a specialty for the holidays that you can get here year-long here.
Text With Image
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet enim.
Text With Image
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet enim.
Text With Image
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet enim.