Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?
Share

Our Reviews

Your satisfaction is our only measure of success. We proudly maintain a 5 star rating across the web. Thank you to our clients and supporters who continue to put their trust in us and share it for the world to see.

Share

Elena M. D'Agostino & Joyce E. Mennella

- Zillow Reviews -

"Hands down the best team to deal with! Elena and Joyce are the utmost professional team, meanwhile treat you as family.Highest recommendations!! We gave Elena power of attorney to take care of closing as we were away.  So comforting knowing that she had "our back" and everything went beyond smooth. Closing within 45 minutes!"

"Many thanks to you and your team at Lucky to Live Here Realty for your professionalism in handling the sale of my home. I was very impressed from our initial discussions on the marketing and pricing, and then the showing of the house, to the negotiation on the final terms."

"Elena and her team are a dream to work with.  Joyce Manella helped us find two houses in two years to rent that met all of our requirements.  She helped us throughout the process and we would use her again in the future."

More Zillow Reviews

- Facebook Reviews - 

"Lucky to Live Here Realty delivers exceptional results every time! Their dedicated, diligent team uses state-of-the-art marketing techniques to help sellers get top dollar for their properties. I highly recommend partnering with Lucky to Live Here for both buying and selling." -  Stephanie Somers

"Joyce and Elena are the best brokers! Professional, down to earth, extremely knowledge and they work really hard and smart on getting their clients the best prices. The best part is that they truly care about their clients. They have introduced us to people in the neighborhood to ease our transition from NYC to the Cold Spring Harbor school district area. My husband and I would highly recommend them! 5 stars all the way!!!!!" - Jaime Blume Meyer 

"A truly professional and experienced team. They were both extremely knowledgable of the current market in the Five Harbor area. They were also very patient and kept us informed and educated throughout the processes of both buying and selling." - Andrea Warner Streater

More Facebook Reviews

- Google Reviews -

"I am a developer as well as a resident In the Huntington area.  Elena, Joyce, and the entire Lucky To Live Here (LTLHR) team is your go to real estate office.  They have sold homes for me and to me from $400,000 to $3,500,000.  Regardless of price every home receives the same attention, and marketing.  Ashley and the rest of the marketing department are the best I’ve seen In the industry.  If you’re looking to buy or sell a home, LTLHR should be your first call." - Rob Dinoto

"We had an excellent  experience with Lucky to Live Here. Elena and Joyce were available to discuss our options and all through the process of selling.  We would be happy to recommend them to future sellers or buyers." - Nancy Ambrosio

More Google Reviews

Active Listings

Achievements

  • March 17, 2015 - Lucky To Live Here Realty was born! (check out our blog on why boutique is better)
  • October 1, 2016 - Opened the doors to our new home at 129 Main Street, Cold Spring Harbor, which includes a Bakes & Kropp's showroom. (see our grand opening photos here)
  • December 2016 - Elena D'Agostino & Joyce Mennella sold the Priciest Homes in Cold Spring Harbor for $2.075M, $2M and $824K
  • June 2017 - Lucky To Live Here Realty Makes Top Real Estate Office in Cold Spring Harbor

Check our our History & Vision here


Closed Transactions

Address
Sold
Title Date
Transaction
4 Saw Mill Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,745,000
6/4/2015
Listed
5 Heckscher Dr, Huntington Bay  
$2,050,000
6/15/2015
Buyer
20 Grove St, Cold Spring Harbor
$950,000
7/7/2015
Listed & Buyer
395 W. Main St, Huntington
$227,000
7/27/2015
Listed & Buyer
W Neck Rd, Lloyd Harbor
$825,000
8/13/2015
Listed
458 Hunt Ln, Manhasset
$1,740,600
8/14/2015
Buyer
2 Seaforth Ln, Lloyd Neck
$1,035,000
8/17/2015
Listed
177 Flower Hill Rd, Huntington
$930,000
9/3/2015
Listed
289 Vineyard Rd, Huntington Bay
$2,800,000
9/29/2015
Listed
326 West Neck Rd, Lloyd Harbor
$1,881,250
10/7/2015
Buyer
420 W. Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
$615,000
10/26/2015
Listed & Buyer
36 Fox Hunt Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,200,000
11/3/2015
Listed
21 Oakwood Dr, Lloyd Neck
$859,000
12/21/2015
Listed
11 Meadow Ln, Lloyd Neck
$912,000
2/2/2016
Listed & Buyer
5 Janes Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$1,225,000
2/17/2016
Listed
12 Kennedy Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,265,000
2/23/2016
Buyer
7 Wawapek Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$2,300,000
2/23/2016
Listed & Buyer
208 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
$840,000
3/1/2016
Buyer
145 Asharoken, Northport
$950,000
3/3/2016
Buyer
25 Forrest Dr, Lloyd Neck
$825,000
4/8/2016
Buyer
20 Grouse Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$998,000
5/20/2016
Listed & Buyer
6 Westview Dr, Lloyd Harbor
$1,425,000
6/15/2016
Buyer
4 Bay Path Ct, Huntington
$815,000
6/15/2016
Listed
53 Hawxhurst Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$749,000
6/22/2016
Listed & Buyer
48 Nimitz St, Huntington
$598,000
6/27/2016
Listed
5 Fox Meadow Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$1,850,000
7/14/2016
Listed
156 Chestnut Cir, Northport
$450,000
7/20/2016
Buyer
80 White Hill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,425,000
7/25/2016
Listed
265 Southdown Rd, Lloyd Harbor
$1,990,000
7/25/2016
Listed & Buyer
16 School Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$982,500
7/26/2016
Listed
29-Unit A Little Neck Rd, Centerport
$860,000
7/28/2016
Buyer
127 Abbott Dr, Huntington
$675,000
8/15/2016
Listed
20 Peabody Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,525,000
8/24/2016
Listed
59 Saw Mill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,825,000
8/25/2016
Listed
3 Huxley Dr, Lloyd Harbor
$1,400,000
8/29/2016
Listed
70 Carley Ave, Huntington
$760,000
9/1/2016
Listed
11 Prospect Rd, Centerport
$800,00
9/1/2016
Listed
9 Elmay Pl, E. Northport
$590,000
9/2/2016
Listed
23 Delaware Ave, Jericho
$845,000
9/28/2016
Listed
420 W. Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
$815,000
11/1/2016
Listed
13 Van Wyck Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$1,375,000
11/15/2016
Listed
5 Puritan Pl, Huntington
$1,680,000
11/29/2016
Buyer
2 Halyard Ct, Cold Spring Harbor
$999,000
12/22/2016
Listed
106 Goose Hill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$2,000,000
1/5/2017
Listed
14 Kennedy Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$2,075,000
1/13/2017
Buyer
56 Turkey Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$834,000
1/27/2017
Listed
1616 Stewart Ln, Laurel Hollow
$2,900,000
2/3/2017
Listed
47 Harbor Hill Dr, Lloyd Harbor
$1,349,000
2/13/2017
Buyer
19 Janes Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$1,500,000
2/27/2017
Listed
516 W. Main St, Cold Spring Harbor
$760,000
3/17/2017
Listed
3 Thea Ln, Huntington
$1,290,000
4/7/2017
Buyer
15 Saw Mill Ln, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,550,000
4/18/2017
Listed
19 Target Rock Dr, Lloyd Neck
$935,000
4/27/2017
Listed & Buyer
26 Snowball Dr, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,359,000
5/1/2017
Listed & Buyer
12 Whaling Ave, Cold Spring Harbor
$599,000
5/1/2017
Listed
6 Donovan Dr, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,640,000
5/22/2017
Listed
4 Brandy Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$969,000
5/24/2017
Listed & Buyer
2 Target Rock Rd, Lloyd Neck
$2,500,000
5/25/2017
Buyer
2 Bouton Rd, Lloyd Harbor
$2,750,000
5/30/2017
Listed
138 Jennings Rd, Lloyd Harbor
$1,375,000
6/2/2017
Buyer
128 Midland St, Cold Spring Harbor
$875,000
6/5/2017
Listed
12 West St, Northport
$400,000
6/5/2017
Buyer
18 School Ln, Lloyd Harbor
$1,669,000
6/9/2017
Listed
7 Poplar Pl, Cold Spring Harbor
$999,000
6/12/2017
Listed
7 Ladder Ct, Huntington
$739,000
6/14/2017
Buyer
33 Dunlop Rd, Huntington
$551,500
6/23/2017
Listed
27 Vista, Laurel Hollow
$2,250,000
6/26/2017
Buyer
301 Woodbury Rd, Cold Spring Harbor
$1,325,000
7/14/2017
Buyer
24 Forrest Dr, Lloyd Neck$700,0007/21/2017Listed & Buyer
5 Lisa Court, Cold Spring Harbor$1,280,0008/4/2017Listed
33 Picardy Lane, Laurel Hollow$1,875,0008/7/2017Buyer
15 Beech Hill Road, Lloyd Harbor$2,150,0008/11/2017Buyer
93 W Gate Dr, Huntington
$1,595,0009/19/2017Buyer
5 Wendover Drive, Huntington$1,950,00010/10/2017Listed & Buyer 
265 Laurel Ln, Laurel Hollow$1,138,00010/3/2017Listed
6 Flower Hill Ct, Huntington$1,072,00011/14/17Listed
19 Northridge Cir, Huntington$550,00012/14/2017Listed
1200 Cove Edge Rd, Laurel Hollow$1,230,0002/1/2018Listed & Buyer
16 Mill Rd, Lloyd Harbor$875,0002/15/2018Buyer
1 Jenning Rd, Lloyd Harbor$2,800,0002/23/2018Buyer
4 Bower Pl, Huntington$569,0002/27/2018Listed
2 White Cap Ct, Lloyd Neck$975,0003/1/2018Listed
43 Harbor Circle, Centerport$1,360,0004/10/2018Listed & Buyer
3 Glen Way, Cold Spring Harbor$710,0004/5/2018Buyer
13 Beech Hill Rd, Lloyd Harbor$979,2004/27/18Listed
7 Wawapek Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$2,152,5005/4/18Listed
165 Asharoken Ave, Asharoken$1,825,0006/4/18Listed & Buyer
3 Norma Ln, Dix Hills$855,0006/6/18Listed
1495 Laurel Hollow Rd, Laurel Hollow$1,525,0006/22/18Listed
41 Lloyd Ln, Lloyd Neck$1,255,0006/25/18Listed
7 Carnegie Ave, Cold Spring Harbor$2,400,0006/27/18Buyer
4 Dogwood Ln, Lloyd Neck$1,500,0007/3/18Listed & Buyer
8 N Soundview Dr, Lloyd Neck$957,5007/5/18Listed
9 Sailfish Pl, Northport$689,0007/11/18Buyer
183 Harbor Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$2,100,0007/16/18Buyer
4 Northwood Circle, Huntington$999,9997/18/18Listed
47 Pine Dr, Cold Spring Harbor$1,155,0007/18/18Listed
3 Middle Hollow Rd, Lloyd Harbor$2,100,0007/20/18Listed & Buyer
48 Hilltop Dr, Laurel Hollow$2,355,0007/24/18Listed
18 Saw Mill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$3,300,0008/2/18Listed
126 Soundview Ter, Northport$1,680,0008/3/18Buyer
3 Caribou Ct, Huntington$1,100,0008/10/18Listed
15 Titus Ln, Cold Spring Harbor$3,750,0008/13/18Listed & Buyer
14 Sherwood Gate, Oyster Bay$1,270,0008/27/18Listed
32 Central Pkwy, Huntington$586,0008/31/18Listed
37 Grafton St, Greenlawn$480,0009/6/18Buyer
4 Coon Hollow Rd, Lloyd Neck$715,0009/7/18Listed
125 La Rue Dr, Huntington$649,0009/14/18Listed
4 Janes Ln, Lloyd Harbor$2,000,0009/19/18Listed
16 Narcissus Dr, Syosset$899,0009/27/18Listed
29 Bouton Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,502,0009/28/18Buyer
7 Private Rd, Huntington$1,075,00010/3/18Listed
1 Homestead Path, Huntington$725,00010/9/18Listed & Buyer
94 Northgate Cir, Melville$648,70210/9/18Buyer
19 Plover Ln, Lloyd Harbor$2,200,00010/16/18Listed & Buyer
2469 New York Ave, Melville$352,00010/16/18Listed & Buyer
11 Vale Dr, Huntington$710,00011/21/18Buyer
6 Quail Hill Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,325,00012/7/18Listed & Buyer
47 Lloyd Ln, Lloyd Neck$1,600,00012/12/18Listed
103 E Neck Rd, Huntington$1,685,0001/16/19Listed
20 Grove St, Cold Spring Harbor$1,050,0001/31/19Listed & Buyer
94 Woodhull Rd, Huntington$645,0002/20/19Listed & Buyer
9 Old Hickory Ln, Huntington$742,5002/26/19Listed
11 Middle Hollow Rd, Lloyd Harbor$2,600,0002/28/19Listed
19 Fox Hunt Ln, Cold Spring Harbor$865,0003/20/19Listed & Buyer
2 Smugglers Cove, Lloyd Harbor$954,0003/21/19Listed
124 Highland Rd, Glen Cove$950,0003/28/19Listed
9 Great Neck Court, Huntington$640,0005/14/19Listed
21 Parkview Terr, Huntington$570,0005/16/19Listed & Buyer
270 Southdown Rd, Lloyd Harbor$970,0005/31/19Listed
46 Wilton Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$1,370,0006/11/19Listed
4 Fox Hunt Ln, Cold Spring Harbor$1,125,0006/13/19Buyer
237 Lawrence Hill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$2,165,0006/26/19Listed & Buyer
52 Wendover Dr, Huntington$750,0007/2/19Listed
1 Wyndefield Ct, Huntington$887,0007/3/19Listed
21 Wayside Ln, Lloyd Harbor$953,0007/8/19Listed
10 Kennedy Ln, Cold Spring Harbor$2,175,0007/22/19Listed & Buyer
6 Kristin Ln, Hauppauge$410,0007/22/19Listed
10 Worcester Dr, Northport$550,0007/22/19Listed & Buyer
95 Jasmine Ln, E Northport$575,0008/1/19Listed
18 W Sanders St, Greenlawn$825,0008/7/19Buyer
28 Terra Mar Dr, Huntington Bay$1,500,0008/12/19Listed & Buyer
17 Beach Dr, Lloyd Neck$1,599,0008/16/19Buyer
4 Mayflower Ct, Centerport$656,5008/20/19Buyer
15 Seacrest Dr, Lloyd Neck$1,900,0008/26/19Listed
8 Saw Mill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$1,750,0008/28/19Listed
88 Centerport Rd, Centerport$569,5009/3/19Buyer
21 Hildreth Ave, Huntington$1,075,0008/30/19Listed
205 Asharoken Ave, Asharoken$5,187,5009/6/19Listed
46 Glen Way, Cold Spring Harbor$989,50010/28/19Listed
40 Spring Hill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$1,705,00011/14/19Buyer
14 Kennedy Ln, Cold Spring Harbor$2,055,0009/26/19Listed
15 E Artisan Ave, Huntington$875,00011/12/19Listed & Buyer
10 Richard Ln, Huntington$999,00011/6/19Buyer
2 Eleanor Pl, Huntington$990,00011/4/19Listed
31 Huntington Bay Rd, Huntington$989,00010/16/19Listed
16 Mill Rd, Lloyd Harbor$915,00011/22/19Listed
7 Grouse Ln, Lloyd Harbor$1,557,50010/25/19Listed & Buyer
14 Sound Bay Dr, Lloyd Harbor$1,900,00012/5/19Buyer
43 School Ln, Lloyd Harbor$1,575,00012/11/19Listed
5 Debbie Ct, Dix Hills$860,0001/7/20Listed & Buyer
30 Middle Hollow Rd, Lloyd Harbor$940,0002/18/20Listed & Buyer
25 Radcliff Drive, Huntington$550,0003/25/20Listed & Buyer
154 Southdown Road, Huntington$570,0004/16/20Listed
19 Fernwood Dr, Commack$516,0004/27/20Listed
8 Woodleaf Ct, Cold Spring Harbor$979,0005/1/20Listed
317 W Neck Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,250,0005/15/20Listed
7 Mulberry Dr, Huntington$635,0007/20/20Listed
17 Woodlot Ln, Huntington$835,0007/29/20Listed
456 W Main St, Huntington$575,0008/14/20Listed
1150 Cove Edge Rd, Laurel Hollow$915,0008/14/20Listed
18 Briarcliff Pl, Huntington$850,0008/25/20Listed
25 Walnut Pl, Huntington$675,0009/2/20Listed
44 Idle Day Dr, Centerport$880,0009/16/20Listed
130 Burr Rd, E Northport$630,0009/16/20Buyer
3 Two Rod Rd, Huntington$3,120,0009/22/20Listed & Buyer
34 Griffith Ln, Huntington$699,0009/29/20Listed
26 Watch Way, Lloyd Harbor$810,0009/29/20Listed
15 Gerry Ln, Lloyd Neck$2,525,00010/15/20Buyer
4 Timberline Dr, Huntington$900,00010/28/20Buyer
90 Woodchuck Hollow Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$999,00010/29/20Listed
226 Southdown Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,260,00010/27/20Listed
9 Mallard Dr, Lloyd Harbor$1,668,04110/30/20Listed
12 Mallard Dr, Lloyd Harbor$1,849,00011/9/20Buyer
208 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor$1,135,00011/12/20Listed
800 Washington Dr, Centerport$785,00011/13/20Buyer
170 Vineyard Rd, Huntington$859,00011/17/20Listed
2 Quaker Path, Huntington$659,00011/18/20Listed
18 Harbor Hill Dr, Lloyd Harbor$1,895,00012/15/20Listed
6 Horseshoe Path, Lloyd Harbor
$737,00012/31/20Listed
142 E Shore Rd, Huntington Bay$1,575,00012/30/20Listed
86 S Harbor Rd, Northport$1,700,0001/13/21Listed
28 The Hollows E, Muttontown$1,480,0001/19/21Listed
12 Middle Hollow Rd, Lloyd Harbor$2,350,0001/25/21Listed
3 Jennings Meadow, Cold Spring Harbor$3,200,0001/29/21Listed
10 E Huxley, Lloyd Harbor$2,000,0001/29/21Buyer
236 Southdown Rd, Lloyd Harbor$2,150,0002/4/21Listed
23 Walters Ave, Cold Spring Harbor
$865,0002/8/21Listed
76 Glenna Little Trl, Huntington$587,5002/11/21Listed
9 Gerry Lane, Lloyd Harbor$949,0002/16/21Listed
150 E Shore Rd, Huntington Bay$2,300,0003/31/21Listed
471B Woodbury Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$935,0004/2/21Listed
1 Crane Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,425,0005/10/21Listed
4 Mayflower Ct, Centerport$825,0005/10/21Listed
12 Alvord Ct, Greenlawn$1,512,0005/14/21Listed
12 Erick Ct, Cold Spring Harbor$950,0005/26/21Listed
34 Schooner Ave, Northport$945,0006/3/21Buyer
16 Briarcliff Pl, Huntington$849,0006/3/21Listed
6 Pond Field Ct, Cold Spring Harbor$2,303,0006/14/21Listed
12 Lloyd Point Dr, Lloyd Harbor$2,012,5006/14/21Listed
214 Fox Ln, Northport$1,390,0006/22/21Listed & Buyer
11 Crane Rd, Lloyd Harbor$1,500,0006/24/21Buyer
1 Midland St, Cold Spring Harbor$1,378,5007/30/21Seller
35 Saw Mill Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$1,437,5008/10/21Seller
30 Harbor Cir, Centerport$1,025,0008/25/21Seller
1 Lighthouse Point, Lloyd Harbor$6,200,0008/26/21Seller
4 Woodfield Ct, Lloyd Harbor$1,437,0008/27/21Seller
8 Wawapek Rd, Cold Spring Harbor$3,250,0009/15/21Seller & Buyer
36 Fiddlers Green Dr, Lloyd Harbor$2,092,00010/7/21Seller


Feel lucky to have worked with us? Please take a moment to share your experience for the world to see! Here's where you'll find us: Google+, FacebookZillow, Yelp 

Featured on News 12

Real Estate Vlog

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies. More info