Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?

Celebrate With A Pie!

Lucky To Live Here Realty

For the love of Real Estate, local businesses and communities of Long Island's North Shore and beyond...

For the love of Real Estate, local businesses and communities of Long Island's North Shore and beyond...

Jun 13 4 minutes read

The Huntington/Five Harbors Area has some of the tastiest and homemade options on Long Island. So grab a fork and make your way around to these absolutely delectable spots. 

Also don't forget National Pi Day on 3.14. 


Blondies Bakeshop- stop in to browse the glass counters brimming with an array of baked goods. Place your orders for holiday pies and keep an eye out for their mobile bakeshop- the Little Blonde Truck.

Hometown Bakeshop- taking orders for their delicious assortment of pies. They have an extensive assortment of savory and sweet pies which are perfect for just about any gathering. We dare you not to walk out with a few more delicious goodies. 

Cold Spring Harbor

photo courtesy of Youngs Farm

Sweetie Pies on Main- brings in freshly made Young Farm pies- the Dark Cherry Pie as seen on Verizon's Restaurant Hunter is amazing! Place your holidays orders early. They also serve miniature pies from Fiorello Dolce.


photo courtesy of Fiorello Dolce

A-Rise Above Bakeshop- these bakeshop goods feel as if they came right out of your oven at home. Choose from a selection of home-made pies and don't forget to take home a box of their cookies and scones.

Fiorello Dolce- make one stop for all your bakery needs including an assortment of delicious freshly made pies in assorted types and sizes. The miniature pies are a wonderful treat.

photo courtesy of Kerbers Farm

Kerbers Farm- when you stop at Kerber's you feel as if you've been taken a trip out-east. Their pies are fresh and delicious. The Smores Pie is a stunner and pleases a crowd- you may need to buy 2!

Hometown Bakeshop (Black & Blue/Farmers Markets/Online)- Hometown Bakeshop products can be ordered online but you can also taste pastry chef Danna Abram's creations at Black & Blue, Southdown Coffee and local Farmers Markets. The miniature blueberry pie is great and if you are looking for a savory option- the Pot Pie is delicious and the Tomato Pie is out-of-this-world.

photo courtesy of Buttercooky

Buttercooky (formerly Reinwalds) is baking up a frenzy with delicious treats ready for pick up and order. Pick from a variety of fillings and pie sizes. 

Wild Flours (gluten free/dairy free)- this bakery specializes in baking items for those with gluten sensitivity but they are sure to please a whole crowd.

photo courtesy of Copenhagen Bakery 

Copenhagen Bakery- pies are one of the numerous bakery items which this harbor-side bakery produces each day.

Hummel Hummel Bakery- choose from a variety of seasonal pies and don't forget to check out their famous pizza crumb.


Briermere Farms- there's no wonder why lines form on the weekends for their delicious pies. Briermere is your East End go-to spot for pies.

Carissa's Bakery in East Hampton has beautiful unique pies to impress the foodies on your guest list. Options include Ginger Caramel Rye Apple and Pear + Cranberry Meringue. 

Jericho Cider Mill - famous for all things apple try their straight apple and apple crumb or head for a mix like apple cranberry crumb or apple peach crumb- yum!

Stay Updated With Local Events, New Listings & More. Sign Up For Our Weekly Newsletter

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies. More info